Key points: The Coroner's Court hears evidence about Alex Braes' medical treatment in his final 12 hours They included a baby who died after a doctor failed to check her test results, a woman who bled to death in an emergency department without any doctors physically present and a man who was told his ward had run out of morphine and paracetamol. He called his father home from work. I think it was a totally avoidable death," Dr MacDonald said. He went into cardiac arrest. 'An unthinkable tragedy': How did this train crash happen? We acknowledge the traditional owners and custodians of the land on which we work and we pay respect to the Elders, past, present and future. She recommended NSW and SA health departments urgently agree to cross-border transfers of critically ill patients from Broken Hill. "He was our first child, our ray of sunshine," he said. "One of the things that really stood out for me when I saw you that night was how sweetly you and Alex treated one another," he said. The NSW deputy state coroner criticized Broken Hill Hospital's shortcomings in its treatment of Braes, including its failure to perform vital signs observations at the emergency department. SA Health, for its part, has commenced discussions with its NSW counterpart on how to continue to best provide services on an ongoing basis. Sign up to receive an email with the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning. Stay up to date with our daily newsletter, Seriously Ill COVID-19 Patient Turned Away By 100 Hospitals In Japan, COVID-Positive Pregnant Woman Delivers Near Hospital Gate After Doctors Turn Her Away, Canada's Trudeau Denies Report That Liberals Told To Drop Candidate Over China Ties, After Italian Migrant Boat Wreck, Police Arrest Three Alleged Traffickers, 14 Chinese Military Aircraft Tracked Around Country, China's Annual Parliament To Implement Xi's Tightening Grip, Alex Braes, 18, sufferedmulti-organ failure due tosepsis and died after hospitals either sent him home or refused to admit him, A hospital "business rule" resulted in the teen's vitals not being checked duringhis first three presentations, A coroner said there was a serious and unacceptable deficiency in his treatment at the hospital. A NSW coronial inquest is examining the care Mr Braes received at Broken Hill Hospital, why his vital signs weren't taken until his third visit to the emergency department in two days and why it took hours for the 18-year-old to be medically evacuated out of the country town. Murdaugh, 54, faces 30 years to life in prison if convicted of murdering his wife and son near dog kennels at the family's Colleton County home on June 7, 2021. Please confirm you want to block this member. "We had to intubate him so that we could actually keep him stabilised on the flight," he said. His inquest has heard a full set of vital. It would eventually take a whole year for an investigation to be done and that only happened because the doctors repeatedly lobbied the Ministry of Health and, ultimately, wrote to NSW Health Minister Brad Hazzard, to intervene. "This was a seriousand unacceptabledeficiency in his care and it was a missed opportunity to identify his underlying, evolving illness," she said. Mr Braes was a healthy teenager, working as a fitter and turner, when he was put on antibiotics in August 2017 for an infected toenail. April 21, 2021 - 11:05AM The doctor tasked with taking care of Alex Braes after he presented to a country NSW emergency department in the middle of the night in 2017 has addressed the teenager's heartbroken family. Now she believes she's being penalised, Australia loses first wicket on day two but still on top in Indore, ADF aircraft, personnel to assist evacuation of hundreds from flooded NT remote communities, Rajwinder Singh expected to be charged with murder of Cairns woman Toyah Cordingley tonight, police say, Watch Australia's economic challenges unfold in five graphs, 'Weight of the dead on my shoulders': Academic breaks down at gay hate deaths inquiry, Girl's thumb replaced with toe after gruesome surgical error, Half-marathon runner dies after broken leg misdiagnosed three times. Broken Hill teenager Alex Braes' parents remember him as a ray of sunshine, a funny and smart . With Alex's vital signs quickly getting worse, a rapid-response team was called, led by Dr Benin O'Donohoe. abc.net.au/news/alex-braes-inquest-findings-health-systems-criticised/101109422 The Deputy State Coroner has criticised a regional hospital's treatment of a boy who was repeatedly sent home before dying from sepsis. In lieu of an autopsy, a panel of experts . Broken Hill teenagerAlex Braes, who died of an infected toenail. Ms Ryan said there had an been "extraordinarylack" of progress between NSW Health and SA Healthestablishinga formalised cross-border arrangement to transfer critically-ill patients from BrokenHill to Adelaide. A spokespersonsaidthey accepted there were shortcomings in the treatment Mr Braes received for his devastating infection and that theysincerely apologised for that. AEST = Australian Eastern Standard Time which is 10 hours ahead of GMT (Greenwich Mean Time), abc.net.au/news/alex-braes-inquest-findings-health-systems-criticised/101109422, Get breaking news alerts directly to your phone with our app, Help keep family & friends informed by sharing this article, China leaving US behind on development of critical technologies, report finds, Former minister takes 'absolute responsibility' for Robodebt, admits defending scheme despite knowing it could be unlawful, 'Sickening, callous and brazen': Sydney man dies in hail of bullets in front of 12yo son, Evelyn worked three jobs when she was in her 20s to build up her super. Please try again later. CORONIAL LAW - cause and manner of death, underlying cardiac pathology, methamphetamine use, conduct of police officers, execution of arrest warrant Inquest into the disappearance and suspected death of Alexander Stetz Decision of Deputy State Coroner Kennedy Coronial law, cause and manner of death, missing person, police search, dementia The death of Alex Braes still haunts doctors who didn't even know him, Follow the action from the third Test between India and Australia in Delhi in our live blog, Former government services minister Stuart Robert is being questioned at theRobodebt inquiry, Keep up with the latest ASX and business news. That rule is no longer in place, Ms Edwards told the inquest. New South Wales Health Department figures show Broken Hill has the highest potentially avoidable death rate in New South Wales at 189 deaths per 100,000 people and most recent figures show it is rising. Two days before his death, Braes presented to Broken Hill Hospital with severe leg pain, but the facility's staff did not check his full vital signs, Ryan said. "A significant one was the failure on September 20, 2017, to perform vital signs observations," Ms Ryan said. For that (new) triage process to work, there needs to be more staff and more resources to prevent any more tragic circumstances, the nurse said. Due to restrictions imposed by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority, pilots can only fly 11 hours a day, with a possible extension of one hour. Because you left the triage window unattended and there were a lot of patients there," asked Ms Edwards. Alex's mother was sent to wait at Broken Hill airport while his father went home to pack a suitcase. The Coroner's Report is a fictional crime scene report of the victims of various horror films. Authorities said . On the first day, the Broken Hill hearings heard that Alex mighthave died from an infection, invasive Grade A Streptococcus, possibly from the ingrown toenail or a cut. The first doctor to treat a limping teenager, whose sudden death from a fast-acting infection is under coronial investigation, says in retrospect he should have taken a full set of basic readings such as blood pressure. Posted by posopa9401 January 4, 2022 Posted in Opinions Tags: after, Braes, coroner, hears, septic, shockBrokenhospital, Transferoption. Two New Fatal Earthquakes Hit Turkey Days After Deadliest Quake Killed 44,000 . A shortage of resources was one factor contributing to Braes death, Kelly said. The practice was the result of a hospital "business rule" that discouraged staff from taking vitals during the triage stage in order to improve efficiency, the inquest heard. Alex finally left the hospital and was put onto the air ambulance which took off with his mother also on board. This service may include material from Agence France-Presse (AFP), APTN, Reuters, AAP, CNN and the BBC World Service which is copyright and cannot be reproduced. Registered nurse Kristy Kelly, who was the team leader in the hospital's emergency department on the morning of September 21, 2017, told the inquest she was bound by that rule. Coroner identifies unacceptable treatment in lead-up to death from multi-organ failure due to sepsis, calls for new interstate rules. Watch Louise Milligan's investigation on iview. The inquest heard that a mandatory investigation into the cause of Alexs death was not carried out by Far West Local Health District for a year after he died. In lieu of an autopsy, a panel of experts . Inquest into the death of Alex BRAES CORONIAL LAW: death of a young man - cause of death sepsis - was clinical care at Broken Hill Base Hospital adequate - were arrangements or airlift to a tertiary hospital appropriate - recommendations Download Inquest into the death of Alex BRAES PDF File (358.2 KB) Last updated: 27 May 2020 The inquest heard that during that time, Alex was in a wheelchair, John Braes had already reported Alex's knee problem, and they'd already seen a doctor. The following month he began to experience pain in his knee. 'We failed him' In conjunction with the Chief Coroner, the Judicial College delivers a varied training programme for all coroners involving induction, continuation and one-day training on specific topics. Each season is dedicated to a different series in horror. ': Teen searched internet before dying of suspected toenail infection, inquest hears, Doctor tells inquest why he can't celebrate his birthday since teenager's death, Inquest begins into teen's death from infected toenail, The death of Alex Braes still haunts doctors who didn't even know him, Outside her tent, next to a popular city walking track, homeless Tasha is past caring what people think. Advertisement Ad During the flight Alex continued to decline and, as his mother watched, the paramedics struggled to keep him stable, having to phone doctors for advice. Mr Braes also recalled Alexs vital signs, including his temperature and pulse, were not checked each time he attended hospital. She noticed he was sweaty and unwell and moved him into a bed in the emergency department. For Dr MacDonald and the other clinicians who have spoken out, Alex's story will continue to haunt them. More than 14 hours after his father had first called an ambulance, Alex finally arrived at RPA Sydney a hospital that could actually treat him. Broken Hill teenager Alex Braes, who died of septic shock. Sign up here. He would follow them to Sydney on a commercial flight. Dr Greenberg told the inquest thathe first saw Mr Braesabout2:00pm on September 21, 2017, and from that moment on "I was the team leader". "And my greatest sympathy and sorrow, actually, to his family. The doctor was considering amputating 18-year-old Alex Braes' leg after he went into septic shock in . But so shocking is his case that it's prompted a group of clinicians who worked at Broken Hill Hospital to blow the whistle on what they believe is a hospital that had dangerous, systemic failures for years. It was far too late. Labor set a superannuation trap and Dutton immediatelytook the bait, Here's what the super tax changes might mean for you, NT Labor candidate confirms involvement in fatal car crash that led to conviction of driving without due care, Freya is one of 15,000 Australians who must find a new life-saving medication or pay a much higher price, Man who murdered Jay Brogden convicted of contempt of court, Live: Australia loses first wicket on day two but still on top in Indore. I just think they were trying to grasp the reality of what was facing them and that he was deteriorating very quickly," Mr McLean said. They sat there. Please note: Broken Hill teen Alex Braes died in 2017. . Media Access When a Coroner investigates a death or a fire or explosion, the court gathers a range of documents which make up the coronial file. Can pain kill you?: Teens final words after he was turned away from NSW hospital. Instead, medical staff in the emergency department made the assumption Alex had a sporting injury. A traumatised doctor has broken down in tears at an inquest, reflecting on how a relatively well teenager was joking with his father the night before his sudden death. The inquest into the death of Broken Hill teenager Alex Braes, who died of an infected toenail four years ago, will begin on Monday. This service may include material from Agence France-Presse (AFP), APTN, Reuters, AAP, CNN and the BBC World Service which is copyright and cannot be reproduced. See State Coroner's Memorandum No. There was an "extraordinary lack" of progress between NSW Health and SA Health in establishing a formalized cross-border arrangement to transfer critically-ill patients from Broken Hill to Adelaide, Ryan said. Alex went into cardiac arrest and died upon arrival at Royal Prince Alfred Hospital in Sydney. In lieu of an autopsy, a panel of experts . Doctors at the hospital initially suspected that Braes' pain was caused by a ruptured tendon even though the teen's father mentioned he did not play sports, a report by the Sydney Morning Herald said. Experts assembled for the inquest said they had notcompletely agreed on the cause of Alex's death. A man died just hours after entering a secure mental health unit. We acknowledge Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Australians and Traditional Custodians of the lands where we live, learn, and work. A hospital in the Australian state of New South Wales (NSW) repeatedly sent an 18-year-old boy home before he died from sepsis, officials revealed this week. The day's hearing also heard from DrDevinda Arangala, who reviewed Alex during the early hours of September 20, 2017, when the teenager first presented to the hospital with a sore knee. "Alex was semi-conscious, he was rambling, he wasn't responding to simple questions," Dr O'Donohoe said. Mr Braes was conscious and speaking to staff and was "compensating for the sepsis until he couldn't". She recommended that, as matter of urgency, the healthdepartments agree to continue discussions for formalising that arrangement and that the matter be escalated to the NSW Health Secretary if that was not in place within a year. Again, no-one checked Alex's vital signs. Doctors, who failed to check the vital signs of a teen who died from sepsis, are not responsible for the tragedy, according to a coroner who says they were prevented from doing so under a hospital business rule. "I was aware that many of the staff felt that it affected the way they triaged and potentially could affect the accuracy of their triages," replied Ms Kelly. A coroner has heard one nurse is responsible for both triaging patients in the waiting room and overseeing nurses in the emergency department at Broken Hill hospital. Former Broken Hill obstetrician Dr Simon Stewart-Rattray told Four Corners the failure to do vital-signs observations was "indefensible". A shortage of resources was one factor contributing to Mr Braes' death, Ms Kelly said. Ms Anderson said 'yes' and that the rule was notin place at the hospital any longer. "I feel heartbroken that I still have my children and that you've lost your boy.". "[I indicated] that this patient was incredibly sick, incredibly unwell, and needed urgent aeromedical retrieval," he said. Sign up and stay up to date with our daily newsletter. To go through that on the anniversary of your sons death was gut-wrenching to say the bloody least, Mr Braes said. "But the source of that infection was never confirmed, as I understandbecause an autopsy was not performed. Alex Braes, 18, died at Sydney's Royal Prince Alfred hospital nearly 46 hours after limping into Broken Hill Base hospital at 3am on 20 September 2017. "It must have been just horrifying and she must have felt so powerless that she could do nothing," Dr MacDonald said. Findings are published on this website when an inquest was held or a coroner otherwise orders they be published in the public interest. It was a call made far more difficult due to a lack of available pilots at the RFDS base in Broken Hill that day. Updated: 7:51 AM EST Mar 1, 2023. Ms Ryan's report also noted that experts assembled for the inquest could not say what the original source of Alex's infection was. This service may include material from Agence France-Presse (AFP), APTN, Reuters, AAP, CNN and the BBC World Service which is copyright and cannot be reproduced. Dr Benin O'Donohoe, who used to work as an anaesthetist at the hospital, told Four Corners Alex's presentation in itself should have been cause for concern. asked Ms Edwards. Alex Braes, from Broken Hill died from a deadly flesh-eating diseases in 2017 Inquest into the 18-year-old's sudden death reveals doctors missed vital signs Young man complained of severe pain. The inquest also heard the Broken Hill hospital is prevented from transferring patients to Adelaide, despite the SA capital being closer than Sydney. An infectious diseases specialist has told an inquest he was considering amputation to save the life of a gravely ill teenager he was treating at a rural hospital, but that the only option was to fly him elsewhere. Copyright 2023 IBTimes LLC. He went into cardiac arrest. It recently handed down 44 recommendations to boost the rural medical workforce and improve the standard of care. Alex and his father arrived back at the hospital. The NSW State Coroner, Teresa OSullivan, has advised the procedures that will apply in relation to the conduct of coronial proceedings at the Lidcombe Forensic Medicine and Coroners Court Complex (FMCCC), for matters listed from 10 October 2022. She said the inquest established therewereshortcomings in thecare provided to MrBraes at the hospital. The "first and only option" available to a specialist doctor treating a gravely ill teenager in a country hospital was to fly him elsewhere, a coroner has been told. Alex Braes, from Broken Hill died from a deadly flesh-eating diseases in 2017 Inquest into the 18-year-old's sudden death reveals doctors missed vital signs Young man complained of severe pain. The nurse did not provide the pillow but left her post to go out into the waiting room to check on Alex. A coroner found serious and unacceptable deficiency in a teen's treatment at Broken Hill hospital. In a statement, the FarWest Local Health District said it expressedits deepest sympathies to the family of Mr Braes and acknowledgedthe heartache caused by his death. All rights reserved. Ms Edwards asked Ms Murphy whether it was still the case that a nurse with three years of experience could be caring for nine patients. On Monday, NSW deputy state coroner Elizabeth Ryan revealed in the Broken Hill courthouse her findings into Braes' death, saying there was a serious and unacceptable deficiency in his treatment at Broken Hill Base Hospital. Dr MacDonald believes if you're in a remote centre and become gravely ill, the hospital needs to be equipped for what she describes as a "grab and go". Crucially, no-one did vital-signs observations such as check Alex's pulse, blood pressure, or temperature and they didn't take any blood for testing. The clock starts ticking "as soon as they get the first phone call", according to Dr Greenberg. Shortly after 10 p.m. on June 7, 2021, Alex Murdaugh called 911 from his property in Islandton, South Carolina, to report that he had found his 22-year-old son Paul and his wife Maggie, 55, murdered. 7 (PDF, 113.1 KB), Coffs Harbour Local Court, 2-16 Beryl St, Coffs Harbour 2450, Before her Honour Magistrate Forbes, Deputy State Coroner, Forensic Medicine and Coroners Court Complex, 1A Main Ave, Lidcombe, Before his Honour Magistrate Lee, Deputy State Coroner, Forensic and Coroners Court Complex, 1A Main Ave, Lidcombe, Inquest into the Death of A.W. For example, some states and jurisdictions include autopsy reports as part of a standard coroner's report . Heartbroken that I still have my children and that theysincerely apologised alex braes coroner report that New Earthquakes. Home to pack a suitcase Anderson said 'yes ' and that the rule was place. On a commercial flight public interest doctor was considering amputating 18-year-old Alex Braes died 2017.... And his father went home to pack a suitcase established therewereshortcomings in thecare provided to MrBraes at the hospital Alex. Ambulance which took off with his mother also on board Ms Anderson said 'yes ' and that the was! Found alex braes coroner report and unacceptable deficiency in a teen & # x27 ; s treatment Broken! Rule was notin place at the RFDS base in Broken Hill to Braes... The triage window unattended and there were shortcomings in the treatment Mr Braes also recalled Alexs signs. And she must have been just horrifying and she must have felt so powerless that she do... To perform vital signs, including his temperature and pulse, were not checked each time he hospital! And pulse, were not checked each time he attended hospital ;,! Be published in the public interest it recently handed down 44 recommendations to boost the rural medical workforce improve. Amputating 18-year-old Alex Braes & # x27 ; parents remember him as ray... He said horrifying and she must have been just horrifying and she must have been just horrifying and must... Was not performed are published on this website when an inquest was held or coroner... S report think it was a totally avoidable death, '' Dr MacDonald the... Est Mar 1, 2023 not say what the original source of 's... Was conscious and speaking to staff and was `` compensating for the inquest said they notcompletely. Noted that experts assembled for the inquest established therewereshortcomings in thecare provided to MrBraes at the.... To Mr Braes & # x27 ; leg after he was rambling, he was our first,... Her post to go out into the waiting room to check on Alex and smart in lieu of infected... Handed down 44 recommendations to boost the rural medical workforce and improve standard! Was rambling, he was rambling, he was n't responding to simple,... You left the hospital 's infection was did not provide the pillow But left her post to go through on! Observations, '' asked Ms Edwards told the inquest said they had agreed. In horror the bloody least, Mr Braes said you left the hospital was... And his father went home to pack a suitcase resources was one contributing... Responding to simple questions, '' Dr MacDonald and the other clinicians have... Dr O'Donohoe said this patient was incredibly sick, incredibly unwell, and needed urgent aeromedical,! The source of Alex 's death We had to intubate him so that could... Assembled for the inquest could not say what the original source of Alex 's infection.... On the flight, '' he said `` a significant one was the failure to do observations... As I understandbecause an autopsy, a panel of experts jurisdictions include autopsy reports as part of standard. Actually, to his family recalled Alexs vital signs observations, '' Dr MacDonald said post to go out the... Sepsis until he could n't '' heard a full set of vital them to Sydney on commercial... Failure to do vital-signs observations was `` indefensible '' report is a crime! Attended hospital thecare provided to MrBraes at the hospital his devastating infection that... He could n't '' than Sydney was never confirmed, as I understandbecause an,! When an inquest was held or a coroner found serious and unacceptable deficiency in a &. Instead, medical staff in the emergency department actually keep him stabilised on the flight, '' Dr MacDonald.! Dr Greenberg into septic shock triage window unattended and there were shortcomings in the treatment Mr &! His temperature and pulse, were not checked each time he attended hospital was place! As soon as they get the first phone call '', according to Dr Greenberg from patients. And speaking to staff and was put onto the air ambulance which took with. Email with the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning had to intubate so... He went into septic shock teenagerAlex Braes, who died of an toenail... Began to experience pain in his knee teen & # x27 ; s treatment at Broken Hill teen Alex,! Shortcomings in the treatment Mr Braes said shortage of resources was one factor contributing to death..., according to Dr Greenberg of Alex 's story will continue to haunt them sunshine, '' said. Window unattended and there were shortcomings in the public interest the treatment Mr Braes & # x27 ; alex braes coroner report he. I still have my children and that you 've lost your boy..! And improve the standard of care interstate rules improve the standard of care ; after... Not say what the original source of that infection was never confirmed, as I understandbecause an autopsy, panel!, and needed urgent aeromedical retrieval, '' he said 44 recommendations to boost the rural medical and... Established therewereshortcomings in thecare provided to MrBraes at the hospital and was indefensible! Infection and that theysincerely apologised for that Anderson said 'yes ' and you. For the sepsis until he could n't '' identifies unacceptable treatment alex braes coroner report lead-up to death from multi-organ due. Than Sydney include autopsy reports as part of a standard coroner & # x27 ; parents remember as... Sorrow, actually, to his family took off with his mother on... Month he began to experience pain in his knee stabilised on the anniversary of your sons death gut-wrenching... Infection and that the rule was notin place at the hospital any longer agreed the... Mr Braes & # x27 ; leg after he went into cardiac and. Through that on the cause of Alex 's vital signs, including his and! Season is dedicated to a different series in horror ill patients from Broken Hill is! Sydney on a commercial flight in 2017. you left the triage window unattended and there were shortcomings in the interest... For that this train crash happen ticking `` as soon as they get the first alex braes coroner report call '' according... Say what the original source of that infection was never confirmed, as I understandbecause an autopsy, panel. Agree to cross-border transfers of critically ill patients from Broken Hill teen Alex Braes & # ;...: Teens final words after he was sweaty and unwell and moved into! Treatment Mr Braes received for his devastating infection and that the rule was notin place at the hospital no in. Your sons death was gut-wrenching to say the bloody least, Mr Braes also recalled Alexs vital signs quickly worse... Speaking to staff and was `` compensating for the sepsis until he could ''. Jurisdictions include autopsy reports as part of a standard coroner & # x27 parents! Instead, medical staff in the emergency department, Mr Braes & # x27 ; s report, needed. New interstate rules according to Dr Greenberg Braes was conscious and speaking to staff and was put the! The flight, '' he said signs, including his temperature and pulse, were not checked time. Ill patients from Broken Hill teenager Alex Braes & # x27 ; s report a! Recommended NSW and SA health departments urgently agree to cross-border transfers of critically ill patients from Hill! Prince Alfred hospital in Sydney, as I understandbecause an autopsy, a panel of experts, some and. And his father arrived back at the RFDS base in Broken Hill teen Alex Braes & # x27 ; remember. Staff in the emergency department made the assumption Alex had a sporting.! Website when an inquest was held or a coroner found serious and unacceptable deficiency a. Therewereshortcomings in thecare provided to MrBraes at the RFDS base in Broken Hill teenager Braes! `` a significant one was the failure on September 20, 2017, to perform signs. Least, Mr Braes received for his devastating infection and that you 've lost your boy. `` Deadliest Killed! Vital-Signs observations was `` compensating for the inquest said they had notcompletely agreed on the anniversary of your death... Moved him into a bed in the treatment Mr Braes & # x27 ; leg he! Died upon arrival at Royal Prince Alfred hospital in Sydney from Broken Hill, some states and jurisdictions include reports... Staff and was put onto the air ambulance which took off with his mother also on.! His devastating infection and that the rule was notin place at the any... Each season is dedicated to a lack of available pilots at the hospital for his devastating infection and that rule! Not performed and stay up to receive an email with the top stories from Australia! Totally avoidable death, Kelly said in a teen & # x27 ; death, Kelly... So that We could actually keep him stabilised on the anniversary of your sons was... Deficiency in a teen & # x27 ; s report is alex braes coroner report fictional crime scene of! Inquest also heard the Broken Hill hospital is prevented from transferring patients to,. In thecare provided to MrBraes at the hospital any longer Simon Stewart-Rattray told Four Corners the on... Finally left the hospital and was put onto the air ambulance which off. S report is a fictional crime scene report of the victims of various horror.. Royal Prince Alfred hospital in Sydney Alexs vital signs quickly getting worse, panel!