Speak with Astrid I completed innocence lost a while ago and I have still not gotten the letter. I get it for the sake of roleplaying and being a hero of Skyrim, killing a bunch of people that are comparable to the hell's angels back in the 20th century when they weren't so polite is usually a good thing. Cicero has been at every DB sanctuary defending it and the night mother . *You could also begin a different quest line starting with Destroy The Dark Brotherhood! In the Abandoned Shack, I do not mind maybe joining the Astrid. However, since I took the other route, killed Astrid when she visited me and got the quest to destroy the Brotherhood, which I later did (she can't tell me what to do! You may not join the Dark Brotherhood after starting this quest though. The core of the dark brotherhood lessons is that good and right is not a clear path. The guide here says only the Oblivion Walker is, but i readed you can destroy the dark brotherhood(its even a quest) before it really start, but does it kills the achievements? Congratulations! The Dark Brotherhood is a group of assassins and they do hide that fact. You’ve joined the Dark Brotherhood!! Hey, I joined them in oblivion and I know they make their business killing, but I don't know if I feel right helping them with this. When you are kidnapped by the Brotherhood and brought to the Abandoned Shack, kill Astrid instead of a hostage and this quest will begin. A chance to activate this quest will appear only during the quest With Friends Like These, where you have to prove your usefulness to the Dark Brotherhood (even before the official joining this organization).You have to lead to a situation, where you'll be kidnapped by Astrid and forced to kill one of the persons held in abandoned shack.Do not kill prisoners but attack the assassin … However, this alone isn't enough. I haven't done any quests involving the Dark Brotherhood yet. That is the turning point in the quest unfortunately there is no good side in the Dark Brotherhood. I feel like the options presented to you during Innocence Lost and With Friends Like These are pretty limited. Cicero respects u and ur title as listener. Posted by 3 years ago. 2 0. ... How do you kill the dark brotherhood? “Destroy the Dark Brotherhood!” is a Dark Brotherhood Faction Quest in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim. Thier base of operations in Skyrim is at the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary near Falkreath. The easiest solution is to kill them all, which is what I did. Page 1 of 8 - Moral Dilemma: Joining the Dark Brotherhood - posted in Skyrim Spoilers: Ever since I saw a comic about a recently deceased guy going to hell because of the terrible things he did in video games, I cant stop wondering if its truly wrong to actually do bad things in video games. During the events of Oblivion, players get invited by Lucien Lachance to join the Dark Brotherhood. Take Abnur Tharn. So I'm playing through Skyrim for the third time now and am trying to do everything exactly how I want to do it lore-wise and I have done almost every quest and questline, but haven't touched the Dark Brotherhood yet. Else you should join, if not for the advantages then at least for the quests and the dialogue. PC PlayStation 3 PC PlayStation 4. Yo I’m going to be posting more Skyrim and shit Every subscribe and like now, lol Everyone go check out a guy called duccs. You can actually just kill everyone in the Dark Brotherhood and destroy it entirely. I finally tried that path myself recently and it's not as bad as I thought. Further attempts to affect the quest using the console seem to fail, breaking Nazir's questline. ... "With Friends Like These," players can simply kill Astrid … 10 3 vote(s) 15.8% never? You could just destroy the Dark Brotherhood. Yes u should spare him . ... IMO, the Dark Brotherhood questline was the best one in the game. When Astrid contacts you she states "Someone isn't leaving this shack alive", meaning she could easily be the corpse. I spent a whole day trying to figure this out . iNooblord 8 years ago #1. Destroying the Brotherhood isn't a quest line and nothing really happens except you kill all of them. yeah, certain dark brother targets have quests that either they or their associates won't give if you kill them. I am not yet sure whether to destroy them or join them and eventually kill the emperor. The Dark Brotherhood is one of the finest questlines in all of Skyrim, and though this group isn’t exactly friendly or good or even law-abiding, you should definitely join … They'll receive a note from a courier with the Brotherhood's symbol, but they then must sleep to trigger the next phase. Keep him alive you fight Astrid. I … However, after reporting Astrid's death, players will eventually receive a note from a courier. The Dark Brotherhood is an organization of assassins that operate throughout Tamriel. Should you decide to kill off Astrid, you will begin a new quest line to Destroy the Dark Brotherhood. Kill him after hunters gone. no, kill astrid the first time you meet her then the quest starts. You can talk to them to get an idea of whom to kill, but I really couldn’t be asked to spend time for the right thing to do so I executed everyone. In order to join the Dark Brotherhood the player needs to first speak with Aventus in Windhelm, and then travel to Riften to kill Grelod the Kind. You can become a murderer for hire... or you can completely wipe out any chances of joining the Brotherhood … From here it’s pretty clear-cut – attack Astrid, the Dark Brotherhood Assassin, to initiate the quest to destroy the brotherhood. Joining obviously gives you many quests, and also a horse and house. Should I join or kill the Dark Brotherhood? You will also be able to retrieve her unique equipment. He is not good nor bad, but a bit in between. Source(s): Gameplay. quest after I join the Dark Brotherhood (DB) and complete all the DB's quests? Astrid will ask you to kill one of the three prisoners behind you, but she doesn’t tell you who. Obviously. ), I was wondering if it's still possible to get her horse some other way and not through the quest. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim Xbox 360 . The Dark Brotherhood quest line is one of the best IMO with a pretty good storyline and I would recommend playing through them at least … This mod overhauls the vanilla Destroy the Dark Brotherhood quest. However, it seems that you can still talk to Astrid to continue the Dark Brotherhood story after some time has passed. the philosophy behind the dark brotherhood is that one who is able to perform the dark ritual, has such a strong feeling that someone has to die, that person deserves to die anyways. Join or kill the Dark Brotherhood? Finding the Dark Brotherhood Sanctuary And you only get the "Destroy the dark brotherhood" quest when you kill astrid. The Thieves Guild beats the Dark Brotherhood by a long shot for me. Do as she says in order to join the brotherhood … One time, kill him one time let him live. This has made it very hard for me to choose whenever to join the dark brotherhood … Welcome to another hardest decision in skyrim where we will be talking about why you should destroy the dark brotherhood, another elder scrolls and skyrim lore topic and another hard choice you will have to make while playing skyrim, however, you are going to choose the correct path and destroy the dark brotherhood! They are called upon by performing a ritual called the Black Sacrement. Before the player was unable to access it no matter what they did. If you kill Astrid, you get a quest that involves destroying the rest of the Dark Brotherhood. And in my opinion, that is not … Cicero is regailed as the Keeper of the Night Mother. The quest plays out normally until you have to report Astrid's death to a guard. If you kill Astrid, all you get is 3k coins when you speak to the guard at dragon bridge, but with doing the Brotherhood quest line you can get tons of coins more than what the guard would give, you can also train your perks when finishing doing a couple quest, if i were you id join the Brotherhood One quest for the Dark Brotherhood will task you with crippling the head of the Emperor's security detail, Commander Maro of the …